Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dirk Hohnstraeter's avatar

A text well worth reading, especially for the way it sincerely probes the subject without pretending to have all the answers. Overall, I think, it offers a fresh perspective on the idea that aesthetic theory should shift its focus away from signs and representation and give greater attention to experience and situation. The line that the Bauhaus “is remembered as a look, but it began as a program for building, particularly building for daily life” captures the point perfectly.

Beyond the Concrete's avatar

Your argument that a photograph cannot substitute for the experience of a building really resonates. We're travelling through Europe documenting modernist architecture, and have repeatedly discovered that buildings we thought we knew from photographs are completely different when experienced physically. Your discussion of the way architectural preference surveys attempt to remove lighting, weather and context is especially revealing. Those aren't distractions from architecture; they're fundamental to how buildings are actually encountered.

15 more comments...

Ready for more?